DANA - Does the Sacred Need an Explanation to Be Experienced?
DANA - Does the Sacred Need an Explanation to Be Experienced?
“Always remember the future”: archetypes, semiotics, predictive perception, and Metanoia—when symbols, memories, and laws participate in creating the Now.
Always Remember the Future
During an ayahuasca experience, accompanied by an Indigenous Peruvian, I heard a sentence that has stayed with me:
“Jackson, always remember the future.”
How can we remember something that has not yet happened?
I do not know an Indigenous word that corresponds exactly to this expression, nor would it be appropriate to attribute it to a particular tradition without identifying the cultural background of the person who said it.
But the question remained.
An imagined future can guide the present before it exists. A child creates an invisible companion. A craftsperson transforms stone into a tool. A community establishes rules that will outlive its founders.
Perhaps remembering the future means preserving the possibility of building what we cannot yet see.
The Future That Remains Behind Us
Rafael Núñez and Eve Sweetser documented a distinctive feature of Aymara representations of time.
In certain linguistic expressions and gestures, the past appears metaphorically in front of us, while the future remains behind us.
The past may be associated with what we already know. The future has not yet been seen.
This does not represent every Andean people, nor does it necessarily explain the sentence I heard.
Nevertheless, it demonstrates that symbolic representations of time are not universal.
The future may be imagined differently depending on each Body-Territory's language, culture, and history.
The Child Who Creates Possibilities
Imagine a child facing a frightening task.
The child talks to an imaginary friend and decides to try again.
The companion does not need to exist materially to participate in a representation that changes how the child plays.
Research on imaginary companions investigates relationships with social cognition and development, without demonstrating that their presence necessarily improves performance.
In the DANA hypothesis, we are interested in how a represented possibility can guide a concrete action.
The imagined future participates in Doing.
And this brings us closer to an expanded definition of religiosity.
Religion Is Also Legislating for the Future
At BrainLatam, we propose understanding religiosity as the capacity to imagine futures and establish rules, commitments, and rituals to guide their realization.
Religion would also mean legislating one's own Doing.
Those who plant expect to harvest. Those who train prepare for future capabilities. Those who work in anticipation of receiving a salary organize commitments in the present.
These activities are not necessarily religious in the historical sense.
But they share something with certain religious practices: expectations produce guidelines for action.
DANA proposes investigating how hope and anticipation become material rules of existence.
Anil Seth: Perceiving Also Means Anticipating
Anil Seth investigates perception as an active construction influenced by predictions and sensory information.
The brain does not simply reproduce the world.
Previous experiences participate in interpreting signals, while unexpected events can modify expectations.
Seth also relates interoceptive inferences to emotional experience and bodily regulation.
This does not mean that imagining something makes it true.
It means that predictions participate in how we perceive and act.
At BrainLatam, we ask how this construction takes place within the symbiosis of Being, Situatedness, and Perceiving.
A Symbol Does Not Mean the Same Thing to Everyone
Charles Sanders Peirce developed a theory of signs in which meaning involves the sign, the object, and the interpretant.
An image does not necessarily hold the same meaning for everyone who observes it.
A stone may represent available material, a tool, or an ancestral object.
A word may evoke protection in one generation and the imposition of authority in another.
The symbol remains recognizable, but its interpretations change.
The screen is a fragment of a fragment: presenting identical images does not mean producing identical experiences.
Meaning participates in the relationship between symbol, history, Body-Territory, and the possibilities for action.
Archetypes: Images That Travel Across Narratives
Carl Jung proposed archetypes to discuss recurring patterns in human experience.
The ancestor, the ruler, the mother, and the savior appear in different narratives, but take on distinct historical meanings.
A 2025 study published in Neuroscience of Consciousness sought to connect Jungian concepts with neuropsychological models.
These proposals remain debated.
There is no demonstration that specific symbolic images are genetically inherited as ready-made memories.
For DANA, the interest lies in investigating how recurring narratives participate in expectations, emotions, and decisions without turning different traditions into a supposedly universal psychology.
The Umbu: When Possibility Takes Shape
A craftsperson examines a stone.
The tool does not yet exist, but producing it requires organizing movements and knowledge.
Archaeological studies document bifacial projectile points associated with the Umbu tradition in different Brazilian contexts.
We cannot directly reconstruct the religiosity or subjective experience of their makers.
But these artifacts testify to material transformations achieved through technical skills.
In the BrainLatam interpretation, we find Sacred Doing: a possibility guides movements that transform the available world.
The resulting object may participate in the actions of other people and generations.
The Incas: When a Ruler Continues to Legislate
Among the Incas, deceased rulers could remain materially present through preserved bodies, ceremonies, and the practices of their descendants.
The panacas maintained relationships with the memory and possessions of royal lineages.
The ritual presence of rulers participated in the continuity of political authority.
The body was biologically dead. Yet its social representation remained active.
We do not need to assume consciousness after death to investigate how objects and rituals evoked commitments and legitimized decisions.
The ancestor continued to participate in organizing the future through the actions of the living.
Chinchorro and Maya: Other Forms of Continuity
Chinchorro communities, in what is now northern Chile, developed complex techniques of artificial mummification long before the Incas.
Among different Maya societies, monuments, burials, and ceremonies also participated in ancestral memory and dynastic legitimacy.
These contexts did not necessarily share equivalent institutions.
Comparing them reveals distinct ways of preserving relationships with the dead through objects, bodies, and places.
In the DANA hypothesis, these material forms may serve as references for evoking memories and guiding behavior.
But preserving a tradition does not guarantee its legitimacy for every subsequent generation.
The Cross: When a Symbol Crosses Different Worlds
The cross can represent love, sacrifice, and redemption for Christians.
For me, it also evokes the violence of colonization and the genocide of Indigenous peoples of the Americas.
This interpretation relates to the documented history of conquest, coercive conversion, and the destruction of Indigenous societies.
However, different Indigenous communities have also reinterpreted Christian symbols, incorporating them into their own practices.
There is no universal experience of the cross.
The scientific and political question arises when the meaning of one tradition is presented as neutral or obligatory for people with different histories.
When Symbols Enter Institutions
In Brazil, crucifixes and other religious symbols remain present in public institutions.
In November 2024, the Federal Supreme Court ruled that their presence was constitutional under certain conditions, interpreting it as a historical-cultural manifestation compatible with state secularism.
This legal interpretation does not eliminate critical perspectives on colonialism and symbolic inequality.
In the DANA hypothesis, we need to investigate what happens when a symbol influences rules and institutions.
The question is not merely which object is present.
It is who can define its meanings and whose experiences are recognized in collective decisions.
Executing, Legislating, and Judging
We propose an analogy involving three functions of individual and collective life.
The Executive represents Doing: carrying out actions, building objects, and investigating consequences.
The Legislative represents the formulation of rules, commitments, and rituals for possible futures.
The Judiciary represents the judgment of conflicts, the assessment of limits, and the possibility of revising decisions.
These functions do not correspond to three brain structures, nor do they replace the constitutional separation of powers.
They are a metaphor for investigating how meanings become actions, rules, and evaluations.
When a belief influences all three functions, it begins to participate materially in social organization.
The Athlete and the Faith That Remains Free
An athlete visualizes movements before a competition.
They train, establish routines, and organize expectations about performance.
A meta-analysis published in 2025, bringing together 86 studies and 3,593 athletes, found benefits of imagery practice for certain indicators of athletic performance.
But anticipating does not mean completely controlling what happens.
High performance requires adaptability.
At BrainLatam, we call embodied faith the confidence developed through practice that remains open to correction.
Blind faith emerges as the opposite possibility: preserving an expectation even when new evidence should change its interpretation.
SfN 2026: Contemplation and Bodily Experience
At Neuroscience 2026, Chhavi Kaushal and K. Megha presented an experiment involving 82 adults and Nadamay sound meditation.
After eight weeks, they reported differences in frontal theta and alpha EEG oscillations and self-reported measures of interoception.
The study offers directions for investigating contemplative practices and physiological conditions.
However, it remains a conference abstract.
EEG does not directly measure Qualia or demonstrate metaphysical truths.
An experience may be deeply meaningful without its religious interpretation becoming scientifically obligatory.
DANA proposes preserving that freedom.
5D Consciousness, Jiwasa, and Metanoia
In the BrainLatam hypothesis, Being corresponds to Tekoha, extended interoception; Situatedness corresponds to APUS, extended proprioception.
Perceiving continuously participates in this symbiosis.
5D Consciousness integrates three material spatial dimensions of the Body-Territory, one Movement dimension, and one Qualia dimension.
Jiwasa represents the possibility of Being with the collective without abandoning individuality.
Metanoia corresponds to reorganization during the very construction of the present.
These proposals enter into dialogue with the Damasian Mind and Alfredo Pereira Jr.'s Triple-Aspect Monism, without being equivalent to them.
Consciousness is a movement that perceives itself as being within the metabolism that produces it.
The Experiment We Need to Build
We could present culturally significant symbols and objects to participants with different territorial histories.
We would investigate how interpretations change after historical information, social encounters, and discussions about rules.
We would record decisions, revisions of expectations, autonomic responses, EEG or fNIRS when appropriate, and first-person reports.
The communities involved would participate in selecting the stimuli and defining their interpretations.
The question would be when memory expands possibilities and when symbolic authority restricts their transformation.
If religion is also legislating for the future, who remains free to reinterpret the laws, symbols, and worlds we have inherited?
Perhaps remembering the future means precisely this: preserving memory without granting the past the exclusive right to determine what we may still Be, how we may be Situated, and what we may Perceive.
Annotated References - Archetypes, Semiotics, Ancestral Memory, and the Creation of the Now
1. Núñez, R. E. & Sweetser, E. (2006). With the Future Behind Them: Convergent Evidence From Aymara Language and Gesture in the Crosslinguistic Comparison of Spatial Construals of Time
Cognitive Science, 30(3), 401–450.
The authors investigated relationships between spatial organization and temporal concepts.
The study demonstrates cultural diversity in representations of time and challenges the automatic generalization of Western metaphors.
It does not allow us to attribute the documented conception to the Indigenous Peruvian who said, “Always remember the future.”
2. Seth, A. K. (2021). Being You: A New Science of Consciousness
Seth investigates perception, consciousness, and bodily conditions.
His approach provides a foundation for examining how expectations influence present experiences.
It does not validate 5D Consciousness, DANA, or any metaphysical explanation of religiosity.
3. Seth, A. K. (2013). Interoceptive inference, emotion, and the embodied self
Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 17(11), 565–573.
The article extends predictive processing research to interoception.
It offers a point of dialogue with BrainLatam's Tekoha hypothesis while preserving the distinctions between these concepts.
4. Peirce, C. S. - Theory of Signs and Semiotics
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Peirce's semiotics provides a framework for investigating why the same object can acquire different meanings across people and generations.
Its contribution to DANA lies in distinguishing the materiality of a symbol from its socially constructed interpretations.
It is not a neurobiological theory of subjective experience.
5. Eigenmodes of the deep unconscious: the neuropsychology of Jungian archetypes and psychedelic experience (2025)
Neuroscience of Consciousness, 2025(1), niaf039.
The article distinguishes archetypes, archetypal images, and symbolic narratives.
It offers a theoretical interpretation of recurring experiential patterns but does not establish that specific symbols are genetically encoded.
The discussion remains open to scientific debate.
6. Constructing Representations: Jungian Archetypes and the Free Energy Principle (2025)
The authors present a theoretical proposal for understanding the emergence of symbolic patterns.
Its contribution lies in formulating questions about cultural transmission and the organization of meaning.
It does not demonstrate a universal neural correspondence for each archetype.
7. Okumura, M. & Araujo, A. G. M. (2013). Pontas bifaciais no Brasil Meridional: caracterização estatística das formas e suas implicações culturais
Revista do Museu de Arqueologia e Etnologia.
The study documents archaeological characteristics of artifacts.
It allows researchers to investigate technologies and material continuities, but not directly reconstruct the consciousness or religiosity of their makers.
The interpretation of Sacred Doing belongs to BrainLatam's philosophical framework.
8. Yaya, I. (2015). Sovereign Bodies: Ancestor Cult and State Legitimacy among the Incas
History and Anthropology.
Isabel Yaya investigates relationships among ancestry, authority, and social continuity.
The study provides a historical foundation for discussing how objects and bodies may participate in political organization after death.
It does not demonstrate the continuation of conscious experience in deceased rulers.
9. UNESCO (2021). Settlement and Artificial Mummification of the Chinchorro Culture in the Arica and Parinacota Region
World Heritage List.
The documentation demonstrates the complexity of the material treatment of the dead.
It does not establish that Chinchorro communities had political institutions equivalent to those of the Incas.
10. The Archaeology of Ancestors: Death, Memory, and Veneration (2014)
University Press of Florida.
The studies examine how monuments, burial sites, and ritual practices participated in social memory.
They provide a historical comparison without presuming a single religion across all Mesoamerican societies.
11. Brazilian Federal Supreme Court (2024). Theme 1086 - Religious Symbols in Public Buildings
Brazil's Federal Supreme Court examined the compatibility of religious symbols with state secularism and freedom of belief.
The decision represents a legal interpretation, not a scientific or philosophical consensus about the meanings of those symbols.
The case allows discussion of the differences between historical-cultural recognition, state neutrality, and divergent social experiences.
12. The Effects of Imagery Practice on Athletes’ Performance: A Multilevel Meta-Analysis with Systematic Review (2025)
Behavioral Sciences, 15(5), 685.
The research identifies benefits for certain performance outcomes.
It does not demonstrate equivalence between athletic imagery and religious faith.
At BrainLatam, this connection guides questions about anticipation, confidence, and flexibility.
13. Kaushal, C. & Megha, K. (2026). Neural Oscillatory Dynamics and Interoceptive Awareness Following Nadamay Meditation Training
Neuroscience 2026 — Society for Neuroscience.
The authors presented results involving 82 adults and changes in physiological and subjective measures.
Because the findings come from a conference abstract, they should be regarded as preliminary.
They do not establish a neural signature of religiosity.
14. Damásio, A. (2021). Feeling & Knowing: Making Minds Conscious
Damásio offers a perspective on the importance of feelings in conscious experience.
His approach connects with the role of metabolism in the BrainLatam hypothesis without being equivalent to 5D Consciousness.
15. Pereira Júnior, A. (2014). Triple-aspect monism: physiological, mental unconscious and conscious aspects of brain activity
Journal of Integrative Neuroscience, 13(2).
This philosophical proposal offers a dialogue among Matter, Information, and Sentience.
It does not constitute a demonstration of DANA or an equivalence with the 5D Consciousness hypothesis.
16. Graeber, D. & Wengrow, D. (2021). The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity
The authors present archaeological and anthropological evidence concerning different forms of social organization.
The book encourages questions about how traditions may be preserved or transformed without treating any single form of authority as inevitable.
17. BrainLatam - DANA, Metanoia, and the Freedom to Reinterpret
These formulations constitute an original conceptual research program open to investigation.
DANA does not seek to establish which belief possesses definitive metaphysical truth.
It proposes investigating how memories, signs, narratives, expectations, and institutions participate in individual and collective Doing.
The decisive question is when the symbols we inherit expand our freedom to create—and when they begin to prevent other futures from being imagined.
BRAINLATAM · W48/2026 · GRAND SUMMARY SfN 2026 · ENGLISH EDITION