Jackson Cionek
20 Views

The Child, the Flower, and the Other - What Beta Bursts Do Not Tell Us About Learning Together

The Child, the Flower, and the Other - What Beta Bursts Do Not Tell Us About Learning Together

From individual differences to the Relational Connectomic Reserve: when encounters open new possibilities for Being, Situatedness, and Perception.

A Flower, Two Children

A child tries to trace the outline of a flower on a sheet of paper. Her hand hesitates, crosses the edge of a petal, returns, and corrects the movement. Another child, sitting nearby, completes the same task effortlessly.

It would be easy to conclude that the first child has less developed motor skills. But what does this comparison actually reveal about their brains?

Now imagine a small change: the second child demonstrates how to hold the pencil, follows the movement, and watches as the first child tries again.

Perhaps nothing changes. Perhaps the first child discovers a strategy she had never attempted before.

What happens in the brain when a task is no longer faced alone?

This scene leads us to a neuroscience experiment published in 2026 and to a hypothesis we want to investigate at BrainLatam: the Relational Connectomic Reserve.

The Experiment That Changed the Unit of Observation

In 2026, Holly Rayson and colleagues investigated sensorimotor brain activity in 41 children: 19 diagnosed with developmental coordination disorder and 22 comparison participants.

Using electroencephalography (EEG), the researchers recorded brain activity while children observed and performed movements, including touching a square and tracing the outline of a flower.

Their focus was on beta bursts: brief episodes of oscillatory activity in the beta frequency range.

Rather than treating brain activity exclusively as a continuous oscillation, the researchers examined transient events that could differ in duration, amplitude, frequency, and waveform.

Interestingly, conventional measurements and the overall occurrence rate of beta bursts did not significantly distinguish the two groups.

However, when the researchers examined specific waveform characteristics, they identified patterns associated with motor performance, hemispheric lateralization, and functional interactions between hemispheres.

Even more importantly, some relationships between burst patterns and motor abilities extended across diagnostic categories.

Motor performance appeared to vary along continuous dimensions rather than simply separating children into two neurological groups.

This does not mean that averages are useless. They answer particular questions. Other questions require us to investigate which events occur, when they occur, and under which conditions.

An electrical pattern, however informative, does not automatically identify an anatomical connection belonging to a neural reserve.

The Same Action, but Now With Someone Else

Another experiment offers an intriguing bridge toward collective learning.

Marlene Meyer and colleagues studied three-year-old children participating in a button-pressing game in which they alternated turns with an adult.

When children observed their partner's movements while participating in the shared activity, their sensorimotor brain responses differed from those recorded when they watched comparable actions without participating in that interaction.

Modulation of mu and beta activity was associated with involvement in the joint task.

Here lies the fascinating detail: it was not only the observed movement that mattered. The child's position within the social situation also mattered.

Watching someone act and acting with someone are not necessarily equivalent experiences.

Meyer examined mu and beta power, whereas Rayson investigated the characteristics of individual beta bursts. These measurements should not be treated as interchangeable.

Together, however, the studies justify a new question:

Could specific temporal patterns of beta bursts also change when a child observes, collaborates, learns from, or teaches another person?

From Flor to Flower

The child already knows the flower and recognizes its Portuguese name, flor.

Someone points to the object and says flower.

The object is familiar, but the sound may be new.

Later, the child may encounter flor in Spanish, a similar word belonging to a different linguistic context.

What happens between the first encounter and familiarity?

Momsen, Schneider, and Abel investigated brain oscillations during the discovery of unfamiliar word meanings through sentence contexts in participants aged eight to sixteen.

Their findings included relationships between beta activity and language abilities, while other developmental associations involved theta activity.

This does not demonstrate that hearing a new word necessarily triggers a beta burst. Nor does it establish that learning simply reduces the occurrence of these events.

Instead, it encourages researchers to examine different temporal units of neural activity during lexical learning.

Bilingualism adds another important dimension: words do not arrive merely as acoustic signals. They arrive through people, gestures, histories, and social situations.

A child may learn one expression at home, another at school, and move between languages without losing their individual identity.

The question is whether the quality of these encounters modifies learning and functional network recruitment beyond the effects of repetition alone.

What Did We Learn When Collective Experiences Disappeared?

During the COVID-19 pandemic, many students continued receiving lessons but lost part of the conversations, games, demonstrations, and spontaneous assistance surrounding classroom learning.

A meta-analysis by Betthäuser and colleagues, covering 42 studies from 15 countries, identified an average learning deficit during the pandemic, with particularly important consequences for socioeconomically disadvantaged students.

It would be incorrect to attribute all these losses to social isolation alone.

Access to educational resources, family conditions, health, and school organization also changed.

Meaningful interactions can also occur in digital environments.

Nevertheless, the pandemic allows us to ask:

Which learning opportunities disappear when certain kinds of encounters stop happening?

In a classroom, another child's explanation may provide an unexpected clue. A classmate's question may reveal something nobody had previously considered.

Perhaps the most productive comparison is not simply face-to-face versus online education.

It is between situations offering different degrees of reciprocity, joint attention, diversity of knowledge, and freedom to participate.

Connectomic Reserve: A Brazilian Hypothesis Encounters the Other

In 2026, Brazilian neuroscientists Roberto Lent, Fernanda Tovar-Moll, and Diego Szczupak proposed the concept of a Connectomic Reserve.

Their hypothesis considers the possibility that anatomical connections established during brain development may remain available for recruitment and reorganization under particular conditions.

The proposal offers an important perspective on neuroplasticity, although its mechanisms still require experimental investigation.

At BrainLatam, we propose extending this question toward the Relational Connectomic Reserve.

Could interacting with another person make functional recruitment possibilities accessible that were not expressed under the same conditions during individual activity?

Perhaps another person merely provides a useful clue, temporarily improving performance.

Or perhaps the encounter generates learning that persists after the partner leaves.

Distinguishing these possibilities is essential.

Neither outcome, by itself, proves that previously unused anatomical connections have been activated.

But consider another possibility: the person providing assistance may also learn.

At one moment, a child demonstrates. At another, the partner corrects, invents, or leads.

Leadership circulates without requiring either participant to abandon their identity.

Being, Situatedness, and Perception as Experimental Questions

The Body-Territory situates the child within material and relational conditions: hand, pencil, posture, environment, personal history, and the presence of others.

Our concept of APUS, extended proprioception, investigates Estar: being situated in different circumstances and relationships.

Tekoha, understood as extended interoception, explores Ser: Being as embodied and situated within those conditions.

Our 5D Consciousness hypothesis proposes five dimensions:

Three spatial dimensions of the measurable materiality of the Body-Territory; one dimension of Movement, including material transformations involved in internal processing and perception; and one dimension of Qualia, the experiential prominence associated with attention.

EEG and movement measurements do not directly reveal subjective experience.

Damasio's approach to mind and organism, together with Alfredo Pereira Jr.'s Triple-Aspect Monism, offer philosophical and neuroscientific perspectives for examining the relationships among materiality, bodily regulation, and experience.

These concepts should generate testable questions rather than replace experimental evidence.

The Experiment We Still Need

Imagine an A→B→A' experimental protocol.

First, a child traces the flower alone.

Next, the child observes another person, collaborates with a partner, or alternates between learning and guiding.

Finally, the child returns to the original task independently.

We would measure movement, precision, learning, and EEG dynamics, using comparable conditions and controlling for repetition effects.

The decisive observation would not simply be improved performance while receiving assistance.

It would be what remains transformed after the encounter.

This transition is where we situate our Metanoia hypothesis: reorganization that participates in the formation of the perceptual present, rather than merely a memory consolidated afterward.

Our future research program on Jiwasa will extend this question to collectives in which leadership emerges and circulates freely.

A Decolonial Neuroscience Begins by Asking Different Questions

Rayson's findings show that the diversity of beta-burst waveforms contains information relevant to motor abilities.

Research on joint action suggests that participating with another person can modify sensorimotor brain activity.

The pandemic revealed the importance of investigating the material and social conditions of learning.

And Lent, Tovar-Moll, and Szczupak offer a hypothesis concerning connectomic possibilities that remain insufficiently understood.

These findings do not prove the Relational Connectomic Reserve.

They provide reasons to design experiments capable of testing it.

A Decolonial Neuroscience does not need to exchange evidence for metaphors.

It can expand the questions we ask, acknowledge individual differences, and investigate the worlds in which every brain learns.

The child is still facing the same flower.

But after encountering the other, is that child still facing the same possibilities?


Annotated References

1. Rayson, H. et al. (2026). Functional heterogeneity of beta bursts in childhood reveals a dimensional neural signature of motor skill. Imaging Neuroscience.

The foundational experiment demonstrates that global measures of beta bursts may fail to distinguish differences associated with motor performance, while specific waveform characteristics reveal functionally relevant variation. It supports investigating individual neural dynamics rather than relying exclusively on group averages. It does not establish that beta bursts directly represent anatomical reserve connections.

2. Meyer, M. et al. (2011). Joint action modulates motor system involvement during action observation in 3-year-olds. Experimental Brain Research, 211, 581–592.

This study connects sensorimotor activity with the social meaning of observed action. Three-year-old children exhibited different neural responses when observing movements within a shared activity. It provides an experimental bridge between individual neural processes and participation with others, while preserving the distinction between frequency-band power and individual beta bursts.

3. Momsen, J., Schneider, J. M. & Abel, A. D. (2022). Developmental differences in EEG oscillations supporting the identification of novel word meaning from context. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 58, 101185.

This research examines neural oscillations during the discovery of unfamiliar word meanings. Associations between beta activity and language abilities support further investigation into the temporal dynamics of lexical learning. The results do not establish that every novel word triggers a specific beta burst or that learning follows one universal neural trajectory.

4. Betthäuser, B. A., Bach-Mortensen, A. M. & Engzell, P. (2023). A systematic review and meta-analysis of the evidence on learning during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nature Human Behaviour, 7, 375–385.

This meta-analysis documents learning deficits during the pandemic and their unequal distribution across socioeconomic conditions. It supports examining learning as inseparable from educational, material, and social circumstances. It does not demonstrate that the absence of face-to-face interaction alone caused these outcomes or that neural reserves were directly affected.

5. Lent, R., Tovar-Moll, F. & Szczupak, D. (2026). The secret connections of the brain: a connectomic reserve for neuroplasticity?. Brain, 149, 2273–2285.

The Brazilian researchers propose the Connectomic Reserve as a hypothesis concerning anatomical resources potentially available for neural reorganization. Their work provides the neuroscientific starting point for our Relational Connectomic Reserve, which asks whether encounters with others can influence functional recruitment and subsequent learning. This relational extension remains a hypothesis requiring direct experimental testing.

6. Graeber, D. & Wengrow, D. (2021). The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity.

This anthropological and historical work provides a foundation for the future Jiwasa discussion. By challenging assumptions about inevitable permanent hierarchies and examining different expressions of social freedom, it encourages questions about how participation, autonomy, and emerging leadership may influence collective learning. Its contribution is conceptual rather than direct neurophysiological evidence.

Editorial note: The English edition preserves the progression from the flower experiment to social learning and the proposed Relational Connectomic Reserve. Jiwasa is introduced as a future research direction, while the central claims remain distinct from the BrainLatam hypotheses.

BRAINLATAM · GRAND SUMMARY SfN 2026 · BLOG 01 · ENGLISH EDITION



#eegmicrostates #neurogliainteractions #eegmicrostates #eegnirsapplications #physiologyandbehavior #neurophilosophy #translationalneuroscience #bienestarwellnessbemestar #neuropolitics #sentienceconsciousness #metacognitionmindsetpremeditation #culturalneuroscience #agingmaturityinnocence #affectivecomputing #languageprocessing #humanking #fruición #wellbeing #neurophilosophy #neurorights #neuropolitics #neuroeconomics #neuromarketing #translationalneuroscience #religare #physiologyandbehavior #skill-implicit-learning #semiotics #encodingofwords #metacognitionmindsetpremeditation #affectivecomputing #meaning #semioticsofaction #mineraçãodedados #soberanianational #mercenáriosdamonetização
Author image

Jackson Cionek

New perspectives in translational control: from neurodegenerative diseases to glioblastoma | Brain States